Little House on the Prairie star Melissa Gilbert
Chantel Brink
Chantel Brink
September 18, 2024 ·  3 min read

Jonathan Gilbert, ‘Little House on the Prairie’ Star ‘Cut Himself off From the Family’ at 18, According to Sister Melissa Gilbert

Jonathan Gilbert, known for his role as Willie Oleson on the beloved television series Little House on the Prairie, grew up in the spotlight alongside his sister Melissa Gilbert, who played Laura Ingalls Wilder. The siblings were both adopted by actors Paul and Barbara Gilbert, and their on-screen success led to a highly visible childhood. While Melissa Gilbert went on to become a household name, Jonathan’s decision to leave Hollywood and distance himself from the family remains a significant part of his story.

A Tight-Knit Family Until Jonathan’s Sudden Departure After Little House on the Prairie

A Tight-Knit Family Until Jonathan’s Sudden Departure After Little House on the Prairie
Image Credit: Showbiz CheatSheet

The Gilbert siblings appeared to have a close-knit family life, at least in the public eye. However, the bond between Jonathan and his family took a drastic turn when he turned 18. According to his sister, Melissa Gilbert, Jonathan chose to “cut himself off” from the family at that time. “I still don’t know what happened,” Melissa admitted in her memoir. “He simply left, emotionally and physically.” This abrupt break left Melissa feeling confused and hurt, a sentiment she has openly shared in interviews.

Read More: Remembering Mac Sinise, Gary’s Sinise’s Son, Who Passed Away at Age 33

The Impact of Jonathan’s Departure on Melissa Gilbert

Melissa Gilbert and her brother Jonathan Gilbert.
Image Credit: Melissa Gilbert Instagram

Melissa has been candid about the emotional toll her brother’s departure took on her. In an interview with AmoMama, she recalled the sense of abandonment and loss she felt when Jonathan decided to remove himself from the family. “It was devastating. I lost not only my brother but also a piece of my identity,” she explained. As Melissa navigated the pressures of her acting career and personal life, the absence of her brother became a painful reminder of their fractured relationship.

Melissa’s Reflections on Their Relationship

Melissa Gilbert and Patty Duke Astin in 'The Miracle Worker'.
Image Credit: Bettmann

Despite the rift, Melissa has expressed that she holds no ill will toward Jonathan. In a piece for People, she discussed the complexities of sibling relationships and how Jonathan’s decision to sever ties was something she had to come to terms with. “I’ve had to make peace with it,” she said. “Whatever his reasons were, I respect them now, but it took me a long time to get to that place.” Melissa’s reflections highlight her journey of acceptance and understanding, even as the specifics behind Jonathan’s departure remain unclear.

Read More: Nicole Kidman’s 16-Year-Old Daughter Is All Grown Up and People Are All Saying The Same Thing

Jonathan Gilbert’s Life After Hollywood

After leaving the acting world and distancing himself from the family, Little House on the Prairie star Jonathan pursued a completely different path.
Image Credit: mr.osmercantile Instagram

After leaving the acting world and distancing himself from the family, Little House on the Prairie star Jonathan pursued a completely different path. He attended business school and eventually became a stockbroker. Jonathan has maintained a life far removed from the public eye, offering little insight into his personal motivations for cutting ties with the Gilbert family. His life remains shrouded in mystery, and unlike his sister Melissa, he has chosen to avoid media attention altogether.

The Gilbert Siblings Today: A Story of Resilience

Image Credit: littlehouseon.theprairie Instagram

Today, the relationship between Jonathan and Melissa Gilbert remains distant, but Melissa continues to speak fondly of her brother, even though they are not in regular contact. In a conversation with Cheat Sheet, she revealed that despite the estrangement, she still loves her brother. “He’s my brother, and that won’t ever change,” she stated. While their paths have diverged, Melissa’s words reflect her enduring affection for Jonathan, even in the face of a complicated family dynamic.

Conclusion: The Unanswered Questions About Jonathan Gilbert

Melissa and Jonathan Gilbert with Alison Arngrim.
Image Credit: Globe Photos, Inc/Globe Photos

Jonathan Gilbert’s decision to distance himself from his family at such a young age has left many questions unanswered. His sister Melissa has shared her own journey of healing and acceptance, but the reasons behind his departure remain a private matter. What’s clear is that the Gilbert family’s story is one of both love and loss, with Jonathan’s absence serving as a poignant chapter in their shared history. Despite the unresolved issues, Melissa’s ongoing love for her brother serves as a testament to the resilience of familial bonds.

Read More: Rare Facts About The Astonishing Melanie Griffith

Sources

  1. “‘Little House on the Prairie’: Jonathan Gilbert ‘Cut Himself off From the Family’ at 18, According to Sister Melissa Gilbert” Showbiz Cheat Sheet.
  2. The Gilbert Siblings: All About Melissa, Sara and JonathanPeople. Melissa Girimonte. December 5, 2023
  3. Melissa Gilbert Celebrates Her Brother Who Once ‘Cut Himself Off’ from Family’s BirthdayAmomama. Julia Pyatnitsa. May 1, 2023.